Marketplaces vs your own online store: where to sell in Spain
Marketplaces vs your own online store: where to sell in Spain
The marketplace temptation, and its hidden invoiceEvery few months a new round of ecommerce events lands in Barcelona and the same conversation comes...
The marketplace temptation, and its hidden invoice
Every few months a new round of ecommerce events lands in Barcelona and the same conversation comes back: should a brand put its catalogue on a big marketplace, or build its own online store? The promise is obvious — instant traffic, ready-made logistics, buyers who already have their card saved. The catch is less obvious, and it usually shows up on the profit and loss sheet six months later.

At a recent industry gathering in the Torre Glòries, one specialist put it bluntly: if a marketplace is going to be your only sales channel, you need a comfortable gross margin before you even consider it. Below a certain threshold, the commissions, fulfilment fees, advertising and returns quietly eat the business. That is not an argument against marketplaces. It is an argument against treating them as a strategy on their own.
What a marketplace really costs you
When you sell through a third-party platform, you are renting demand. You pay for it in several ways at once:
- Commission and fulfilment fees that scale with volume but never disappear.
- Paid visibility, because organic ranking inside a marketplace is crowded and competitive; advertising helps, but only when it is measured against real contribution margin rather than vanity sales.
- Price pressure, as your listing sits next to near-identical products and the buyer sorts by price.
- Zero ownership of the customer: no email list you can use freely, no first-party data, no direct relationship after the sale.
There is also a practical detail that catches Spanish retailers out: the platform owns the checkout experience, the cookie consent and much of the data processing. Under GDPR, responsibilities get shared in ways that are rarely explained clearly to the seller. If your own store is the place where consent, accounts and marketing permissions live, you keep control of the relationship — and of the compliance story you can actually explain to a customer or an auditor.
The case for a store you actually own
A well-built online store is not a vanity project. It is the asset that compounds: every visit, every newsletter signup, every repeat purchase and every product review belongs to you. In Catalonia, where many retail brands start with one or two physical shops in Lleida, Girona or Tarragona before going national, that asset is what makes the jump to online sustainable rather than a one-off spike.
Owning the store also means owning the margin structure. You decide the pricing, the bundles, the loyalty scheme and the cross-sell. You can run a promotion on a slow-moving line without asking a platform for permission, and you can test a new category with a landing page instead of a full catalogue upload.
PrestaShop or WooCommerce: pick by how you sell, not by hype
For most Spanish and European merchants, the realistic choice comes down to two open-source platforms, and both can be shaped around the business rather than the other way round.
PrestaShop tends to suit catalogues with many variants, attributes and combinations, where stock, tax rules and carrier logic get complicated fast. It is a solid fit for B2B catalogues with customer-specific pricing, and it has a long track record among European retailers.
WooCommerce is the natural option when content and commerce live together: a WordPress site where the blog, the product pages and the SEO strategy share one codebase. It is flexible, well documented and easy to extend with custom plugins when an off-the-shelf module does not quite fit.
Neither platform sells by itself. What converts is the work around it: fast, mobile-first product pages, clean checkout with the payment methods Spanish buyers expect, transparent delivery costs, stock accuracy, and a search that actually finds what the customer typed. Conversion optimisation is not a one-off redesign — it is a routine of measuring, changing one thing and measuring again.
A channel mix that protects the margin
The sensible approach for most brands is not marketplace versus own store, but a deliberate mix with clear roles:
- Use marketplaces to acquire customers and test demand in categories where you have no audience yet.
- Use your own store as the home of the brand, the loyalty programme and the customer data.
- Include the marketplace commission in your unit economics from day one, so a channel that looks busy but loses money is visible early.
- Keep product content, imagery and video consistent across channels — good creative lowers acquisition cost everywhere.
On artificial intelligence, the pragmatic view from the sector is worth repeating: it is genuinely useful for copy drafts, product descriptions and support triage, but it should not be trusted blindly for pricing or stock decisions. The judgement still sits with people who know the catalogue.
Where to start
If you already sell in a physical shop in Lleida or online through a marketplace and want a store that genuinely sells, the first step is not a platform decision but a numbers decision: what margin do you need per order, which channels feed which customers, and what data do you want to own in two years. Once that is clear, a tailored PrestaShop or WooCommerce build — with conversion work, analytics and the surrounding stack — turns the plan into something you can measure month by month, in euros and in repeat customers.
Related
- WooCommerce vs PrestaShop: Which Ecommerce Platform Wins in 2025?
- CRO for Ecommerce: Turning WooCommerce and PrestaShop Templates into Sales Engines
- Agentic Commerce: How AI Agents Are Rewriting the Rules of Online Shopping
- Desarrollo web
Put these ideas into practice
Talk to ALMC about a solution for your business. Explore your options or contact our team.
